Devolution: The Idea vs. The Reality

Politicians often promise that devolution will bring decision-making closer to the people. But what’s really happening in Hampshire and the Solent?

Instead of empowering local communities, the current devolution deal risks creating another remote layer of government: a directly elected Mayor with sweeping powers, new offices, and more bureaucracy.

Who Is Involved in the Hampshire and Solent Combined County Authority (CCA)?

The proposed CCA brings together parts of Hampshire and the Solent region. Here’s who’s in:

• Hampshire County Council — leading the push for the CCA.
• Southampton City Council — backing the plan.
• Portsmouth City Council — backing the plan.
• Isle of Wight Coun Council  –  Initial reservations. 

Who Has Opted Out?

Several councils have decided not to join or have raised serious concerns:

• New Forest District Council — formally opposed.
• Test Valley Borough Council — formally opposed.
• Havant Borough Council — concerned about reduced local control.
• Fareham Borough Council — sceptical about mayoral governance.
• Gosport Borough Council — critical of further centralisation.
• East Hampshire District Council — cautious and critical.
• Winchester City Council — neutral to sceptical.

Additionally, Isle of Wight Council initially showed interest but later withdrew, pursuing its own devolution plan.

Many town and parish councils have also expressed opposition during consultations.

What the Consultation Said

• Public Responses: Over 50% of residents voiced concerns about losing local accountability.
• District and Borough Councils: A majority expressed opposition or scepticism, mainly regarding the mayoral structure.
• City Councils (Southampton, Portsmouth): Supportive, seeing potential for increased investment.
• Isle of Wight: Opted for its own “Island Deal”.
• Businesses: Larger firms were supportive; smaller businesses worried about being overlooked.